Cyberstability Update – October 2019

Cyberstability Update – October 2019

November 10, 2019, Monthly update

Download Publication Download Document

Cyberstability Update – October 2019

Global Commission to Release Final Report in November at Paris Peace Forum

On Tuesday 12 November, the Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace (GCSC) will release its final report at the Paris Peace Forum. The report represents the culmination of the Commission’s efforts over the past three years, offering norms and policies for enhancing stability at this critical juncture in the future of cyberspace.

The full report of the Commission will be available online on 12 November. Visit the website www.cyberstability.org to find out more about the Commission and its proposals, or follow the GCSC updates on the launch of the report on social media (@theGCSC).

Read more


Cyberstability Update – October 2019

GLOBAL COMMISSION MEETING IN ADDIS ABABA, ETHIOPIA

Published on the Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace Website on September 9, 2019.

The Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace held its fourth meeting of 2019 in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, on 11-12 October. The Commission meeting took place just after the Global Forum on Cyber Expertise (GFCE) Annual Meeting, hosted by the African Union Commission.

On Friday 11 October the GCSC held public Cyberstability Hearings, in partnership with the GFCE and hosted by the African Union Commission. The Hearings were dedicated to “Norm Implementation & Capacity Building: Two Sides of the Same Coin?”. The Hearings were conducted in an expanded roundtable format and featured discussions between GCSC Commissioners and representatives from government, the private sector and civil society on matters pertaining to international peace and security in cyberspace.

Read More


The Netherlands Releases a Tour de Force on International Law in Cyberspace: Analysis  

This article by Michael Schmitt was published by  Just Security, 14 October 2019.  

In a July 2019 letter to parliament, the Dutch Minister of Foreign Affairs set out the Government’s views on “the application in cyberspace of relevant elements of existing international law.” That letter now has been made public. It is an extremely granular statement, not only in terms of scope, but also with respect to the legal basis for the position taken. As such, it is a major contribution to the growing body of opinio juris on the subject that includes the recently released French Ministry of Armie’s International Law Applicable to Operations in Cyberspace(see herehere, and here), the Estonian President’s speech this year, the UK Attorney General’s Chatham House speech last year,  and Australia’s current International Cyber Engagement Strategy (annex on international law). 

Read the letter to parliament here


Global Governance


Sovereignty in Cyberspace paper unveiled, China Daily   

Tags: GCSC Commissioner Zhang Li.


Episode 23: The rise of China, technology and a Sino-centric world order, IISS 

Tags: GCSC Commissioner Nigel Inkster.


Could China’s strict cyber controls gain international acceptance?, South China Morning Post 

Tags: Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace. 


How the cyberspace narrative shapes governance and security, ORF 

Tags: GCSC Commissioner James Andrew Lewis. 


Can Cyberwarfare Be Regulated?, Belfer Center 

Tags: GCSC Commissioner Joseph Nye. 


Lunch Panel: The Wassenaar Arrangement: What it Means for the Future of Global Cybersecurity, IICS 

Tags: GCSC Commissioner Jeff Moss.


Cyberspace Law eJournal, SSRN. 

Tags: GCSC Commissioner Jonathan Zittrain. 


Unpacking the GGE’s Framework on Responsible State Behaviour: Capacity Building, Global Partners Digital. 

Tags: Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace


Key Takeaways form the AU GGE Consultation, Global Partners Digital 

Tags: Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace. 


NATO Allies Need to Come to Terms With Offensive Cyber Operations, Lawfare 

Tags: GCSC Norm for States to Create a Vulnerability Equities Process. 


Member States publish a report on EU coordinated risk assessment of 5G network security, European Commission

Tags: GCSC Norm to Protect the Public Core of the Internet. 


Europe Overly Dependent on Outside Technology, EU Memo Warns, Bloomberg.   

Tags: Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace.


Europe postures with standards leadership still on the line, Telecom 

Tags: GCSC Special Representative Carl Bildt.


EU cybersecurity rules: Commission’s report shows how Member States have identified “essential services”, European Commission 

Tags: Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace.


#CyFy2019 | Welcome Address | Samir Saran, ORF 

Tags: GCSC Commissioner Samit Saran.


 #CyFy2019 | Unifying Narratives in a Fractured World: The Role of the GCSC, ORF 

Tags: GCSC Co-Chair Latha ReddyGCSC Commissioner Samir Saran. 


National Policy


Egypt Curbs Online Dissent With Street Searches: ‘He Asked to See My Phone’, The Wall Street Journal 

Tags: Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace. 


Egypt Is Using Apps to Track and Target Its Citizens, Report Says, The New York Times. 

Tags: Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace.


An Open Letter to the American People, JustSecurity 

Tags: GCSC Commissioner Christopher Painter. 


White House cybersecurity chief quits, says leadership is inviting an attack, TNW 

Tags: Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace.


U.S. Navy to Appoint Cyber Chief Following a Blistering Audit, The Wall Street Journal 

Tags: GCSC Norm on Basic Cyber Hygiene as Foundational Defense.


Why did Cyber Command back off its recent plans to call out North Korean hacking?, CyberScoop 

Tags: Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace.


Cyber rules for self-driving cars stall in Congress, The Hill 

Tags: GCSC Norm on Basic Cyber Hygiene as Foundational Defense.


Cyber Storm 2020 could be DHS’s most rigorous drill for critical infrastructure yet, CyberScoop.

Tags: GCSC Norm on Basic Cyber Hygiene as Foundational Defense.


DHS is mulling an order that would force agencies to set up vulnerability disclosure programs, CyberScoop 

Tags: GCSC Norm to Create a Vulnerability Equities Proces.


Iran checks cyber security at key energy sites, eyes U.S. threat, Reuters 

Tags: GCSC Norm on Basic Cyber Hygiene as Foundational Defense.


The Academic Reserve, Berhahn. 

Tags: GCSC Commissioner Isaac Ben-Israel.


3 reasons why data is not the new oil – and why this matters to India, WEF 

Tags: GCSC Commissioner Samir Saran.


Will China’s revised cybersecurity rules put foreign firms at risk of losing their secrets?, South China Morning Post 

Tags: Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace.


Hong Kong and the future of ‘one party, two systems’, IISS. 

Tags: GCSC Commissioner Nigel Inkster. 


Threats and Risk Mitigation


North Korea’s KCNA, Russian TASS news agency hope to fight ‘fake news’, BBC 

Tags: Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace.


North Korea is using front companies to steal cryptocurrency, CyberScoop 

Tags: Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace. 


As technology advances, so do the complexities of the cyber threats targeting the nation, Nextgov.    .    

Tags: GCSC Norm to Protect the Public Core of the Internet.


No one could prevent another ‘WanneCry-style’ attack, says DHS official, TechCrunch

Tags: GCSC Norm to Reduce and Mitigate Significant Vulnerabilities.


Report: Nation state hackers and cyber criminals are spoofing each other, ZDNET 

Tags: GCSC Norm to Reduce and Mitigate Significant Vulnerabilities. 


US: Russian hackers use Iranians to mask their identities, The Washington Post 

Tags: GCSC Norm Against Offensive Cyber Operations by Non-State Actors.


Czech authorities dismantle alleged Russian cyber-espionage network, ZDNet 

Tags: Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace.


Podcast Interview with “Father of the Internet” Vint Cerf, CCC 

Tags: GCSC Special Advisor Vint Cerf. 


 Conflict in Cyberspace


China and The Risk of Cyberwarfare, Institute of Art and Ideas. 

Tags: GCSC Commissioner Nigel Inkster.


50 years after Internet conception, dark side stirs fear, Yahoo 

Tags: GCSC Commissioner Olaf Kolkman.


Emerging Technologies and Next Generation Arms Control, CSIS 

Tags: GCSC Commissioner James Andrew Lewis. 


Industry and Civil Society Developments


The State of OT cybersecurity in the utilities industry, Atlantic Council. 

Tags: GCSC Co-Chair Michael Chertoff.


A Controversial Plan to Encrypt More of the Internet, WIRED 

Tags: GCSC Norm to Protect the Public Core of the Internet.


NASS released a compendium of government, private-sector and academic organizations that can provide state officials with digital security recommendations and services, National Association of Secretaries of State.

Tags: GCSC Norm to Protect the Electoral Infrastructure.


Expanding Disclosure Policy to Drive Better Cybersecurity, CFR 

Tags: GCSC Norm on Basic Cyber Hygiene as a Foundational Defense.


Industry Leaders Throw Weight Behind Interoperability Alliance, InfoSecurity 

Tags: GCSC Norm to Reduce and Mitigate Significant Vulnerabilities. 


Google Draws House Antitrust Scrutiny of Internet Protocol, The Wall Street Journal  

Tags: GCSC Norm to Protect the Public Core of the Internet. 


Apple, Google Pull Hong Kong Protest Apps Amid China Uproar, The Wall Street Journal 

Tags: Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace. 


Sberbank data breach: Russian lender investigates insider threat, The Daily Swig 

Tags: GCSC Commissioner Ilya Sachkov. 


Breach Updates


APT trends report Q3 2019, SecureList 

Tags: GCSC Norm Against Offensive Cyber Operations by Non-State Actors.


New cyberattacks targeting sporting and anti-doping organizations, Microsoft 

Tags: Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace.


Top Secret Russian Unit Seeks to Destabilize Europe, Security Officials Say, The New York Times 

Tags: GCSC Norm to Protect the Electoral Infrastructure.


In echo of 2008 war with Russia, Georgia hit with massive cyberattack, The Washington Post 

Tags: Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace.


UK investigation reveals Russian hackers impersonated Iranian hackers, CODA 

Tags: Director of the GCSC Secretariat Alexander Klimburg.


Number of Cyberattacks on Russian Companies Has Significantly Increased – Cybersecurity Company CEO, Sputnik.

Tags: GCSC Commissioner Ilya Sachkov.


Exclusive: U.S. carried out secret cyber strike on Iran in wake of Saudi oil attack: officials, Reuters  

Tags: Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace. 


Democracy and Electoral Infrastructure


Russian Active Measures Campaigns and Interference in the 2016 U.S. Election Volume 2: Russia’s use of Social Media with Additional Views, Select Committee on Intelligence United States Senate.   

Tags: GCSC Norm to Protect the Electoral Infrastructure. 


Facebook discloses operations by Russia and Iran to meddle in 2020 election, The Guardian.

Tags: GCSC Norm to Protect the Electoral Infrastructure.  


Iranian attacks expose vulnerability of campaign email accounts, The Hill.  

Tags: GCSC Norm to Reduce and Mitigate Significant Vulnerabilities, GCSC Norm to Protect the Electoral Infrastructure. 


Former officials flag disinformation as top threat to U.S. elections, FCW.

Tags: GCSC Co-Chair Michael Chertoff. 


 Others


Full Event: Origins of the Internet with Vint Cerf, Steve Crocker, and Radia Perlman, NSTMF.

Tags: GCSC Special Advisor Vint Cerf.


Democracy and the Tech Revolution: A Conversation with Marietje Schaake, Power 3.0 

Tags: GCSC Commissioner Marietje Schaake. 


Welcome to the age of the platform nation, WEF 

Tags: GCSC Commissioner Samir Saran.


DNS-over-HTTPS causes more problems than it solves, experts say, ZDNet  

Tags: GCSC Norm to Protect the Public Core of the Internet.


Global Norms for Stable Cyber Space: How Effective without Secure Supply Chain and Attribution to Attackers?, VIF.

Tags: Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace. 


Russian indicted by Mueller held in Berlarus, then released, The Washington Post 

Tags: GCSC Norm to Protect the Electoral Infrastructure. 


Ukranian cops just arrested an alleged hacker in one of Kyiv’s ‘most expensive’ hotels, CyberScoop  

Tags: Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace.


U.S. agrees to help Baltic states bolster grid cybersecurity, CyberScoop 

Tags: GCSC Norm to Protect the Electoral Infrastructure.


Digital crossroads: Unlocking the potential of India-US cooperation in cyberspace, ORF 

Tags: GCSC Commissioner Samir Saran.


Presentation of project GEODE, GEODE 

Tags: GCSC Commissioner Frédérick Douzet. 


 Events


4 October 2019: The state of OT cybersecurity in the utilities industry, Atlantic Council


8-10 October 2019: GFCE Annual Meeting 2019, GFCE.


11-12 October 2019: GCSC Meeting in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, GCSC


14-16 October 2019: CyFy, ORF.


20-22 October 2019: 6th World Internet Conference Wuzhen Summit, Wuhzen Summit.  


21-25 October 2019: Cyberweek, CyberScoop.


27-31 October 2019: Regional Cybersecurity Week 2019, ARCC.


28-29 October 2019: AI Ethics, Policy, and Governance, Stanford University.


29-30 October 2019: Cybersec 2019, European Cybersecurity Forum.


 30 October 2019: The implications of Deep Fakes, CSIS.  


11-15 November 2019: Singapore FinTech Festival, fintechfest.


12-13 November 2019: Paris Peace Forum, PPF.


25-29 November 2019: Internet Governance Forum, IGF.


28-29 November 2019: CyberCrimeCon 2019 – Singapore, Qwoted.


2-5 December 2019: Black Hat Europe, Blackhat.  


28-30 January 2019: International Cybersecurity Forum, FIC.